For property managers

Towing from a Utah apartment lot: the photo shows a car in a stall, the signs at each entrance and the tow company’s report decide whether the tow holds up

A resident at a Utah apartment community parks overnight in a stall marked “Reserved”. By morning the car has been towed. The resident pays the tow company, then emails you a phone photo of the sign at the main entrance and a demand: the sign is wrong, the tow was illegal, the community should pay them back. The tow company sends its own photo, of the car sitting in the reserved stall. Both photos may be perfectly real. But a photo of a car in a stall doesn’t show which kind of towing your property is set up for, whether every entrance had the right sign that night, or whether the tow company filed the reports that let it charge at all. In Utah those things are set out in one statute, and most of them are records, not pictures. This piece covers what that statute says and what to check when a resident disputes a tow. It is not legal advice.

Why the photos can’t settle it

The tow company’s photo shows a car in a stall. It doesn’t show that the stall was signed as reserved for someone else, that the lot had the required signs at each entrance, or who asked for the tow. The resident’s photo of a sign shows one sign, at one entrance, on whatever day the photo was taken. A lot with three entrances needs a sign at all three, and a sign photographed the morning after says nothing certain about the night before.

The sign photo is still worth more than most damage photos, because some of what Utah requires of a sign is visible: its colors, its wording, the tow logo and a web address. That is covered below. Its size isn’t visible without something in the frame for scale.

Three ways a Utah property can enforce parking

Utah Code 72-9-603 lets a private property owner, “subject to the requirements of a local ordinance”, enforce parking restrictions in one of three ways (603(4)(a)):

  1. A patrolled lot. “authorizing a tow truck motor carrier to patrol and monitor the property and enforce parking restrictions on behalf of the property owner”. The agreement for this “shall include specific terms and conditions for the tow truck motor carrier to remove a vehicle” (603(4)(b)(i)).
  2. Tows on request. “requesting a tow from a tow truck motor carrier on a case-by-case basis”. Here the tow company “may not” patrol the property, may not act as your agent to request a tow, and may not tow “without the written or verbal request of the property owner or the property owner’s agent” (603(8)(a)).
  3. A 24-hour notice. “requesting a tow from a tow truck motor carrier after providing 24-hour written notice” (603(4)(a)(iii)). This is the route for property “without signage substantially meeting the requirements” of the first two (603(9)(a)).

So the first question isn’t about the photo. It is which of the three your property uses, and the record that goes with it: the patrol agreement, a record of who at your office asked for this tow and when, or the notice that was put on the car.

Before any of that, the statute says a tow company may not tow at a property owner’s request unless the car’s owner or a lienholder consents, or “the property owner erects signage” that meets the requirements (603(3)(a)). The 24-hour notice route is the exception for lots without that signage (603(9)).

What the signs must say

For a patrolled lot, “each entrance to the property” needs signs “clearly visible to the driver of a vehicle entering the property” that “substantially comply” with this (603(7)):

For tows on request, each entrance needs one “clearly visible sign”, also 24 by 18 inches: a blue top with the towing logo and “Towing Enforced”, a red middle saying who may park and which vehicles may not, and a white bottom with red letters giving either your name and number or the tow company’s, and “tow.utah.gov” (603(8)(b)).

There are more sign rules for some lots. A property “who allows public parking” must also post “clear instructions for parking at the property” (603(4)(b)(ii)). Where one lot spans parcels with different rules, signs go at each entrance between them, or every 40 feet or less along the dividing line. Where there is no clear entrance from the road, signs go every 40 feet or less along the property line where a car can drive in (603(4)(b)(iii), (iv)).

Who decides whether a sign is close enough? “If a dispute arises regarding whether a sign required under this section substantially complies with the requirements of this section, the department shall determine whether the sign substantially complies” (603(8)(c)). In this title, “department” means the Utah Department of Transportation. The department must publish “illustrated or photographed examples” of the signs and the notice (603(10)).

The reason the signs matter to you: “It is an affirmative defense to any claim, based on the lack of notice, that arises from the towing of a vehicle, vessel, or outboard motor from private property that the property had signage meeting the requirements” (603(11)).

What a photo of a sign can and can’t show

Tows that don’t need the signs

The sign and notice rules in subsections (7) through (9) “do not apply” to a tow from (603(3)(b)):

This is where a car photo does real work. A fire lane tow turns on where the car was, and a photo that shows the car, the red curb and the fire lane marking says a lot about that. It still doesn’t show the date, and a photo of the same car in the same place from another night would look the same. Ask for the tow company’s record of the time of removal, which it has to report anyway (next section).

The 24-hour notice

On a lot without compliant signs, you or your agent may have a car towed “24 hours after” a written notice is put on it (603(9)(a)). The notice must (603(9)(b)):

A tow company may put the notice on for you if you authorize it (603(9)(c)). A photo of the notice on the window is a good thing to keep, because it shows the notice, its size against the glass and which window it was on. But the time that counts is the one written on the notice. The photo’s own time stamp is a second clock, and it can disagree.

What the tow company has to do afterwards

For a tow done “without the vehicle, vessel, or outboard motor owner’s knowledge”, and not ordered by police or a highway authority, the tow operator or company must (603(1)):

Until the database report is made, the tow company “may not” collect any removal fee or “begin charging storage fees” (603(2)(a)). A company that “fails to provide timely and proper notice” “forfeits the right to collect or enforce any towing, storage, or impound fees” from the owner or lienholder (603(22)(a)).

If the owner says notice wasn’t given, “there is a rebuttable presumption that notice was not properly provided”. The company rebuts it with “credible, time-stamped evidence” that it made the database report or sent the certified letter (603(22)(d)). That is the statute’s own answer to what counts as proof here, and it is a filing and a mailing receipt, not a picture of the car.

Fees are capped too. The owner is “only responsible for paying” tow and storage fees set under the department’s rules, and the administrative impound fee “if applicable” (603(12)). A company may charge “up to the maximum rate” the department sets (603(18)(a)(i)), plus a card fee “of 3% of the transaction total” (603(18)(a)(ii)). It must take “cash and debit or credit card” (603(15)(b)), have someone answering “by phone 24 hours a day, seven days a week”, and release the car “within one hour” of the owner’s call (603(19)). We haven’t read the department’s rate rules and don’t quote any amounts.

These are the tow company’s duties, not yours. But a resident who asks you to pay a tow bill back is often really disputing the tow company’s fees, and the records above are the tow company’s to produce.

Checks when a resident disputes a tow

  1. Find out which of the three routes your property uses (603(4)(a)), and pull its record: the patrol agreement and its “specific terms and conditions” for removal, or the request your office made for this tow (who, when, written or by phone), or the 24-hour notice.
  2. Check the sign in the resident’s photo against the right list (603(7) for a patrolled lot, 603(8)(b) for tows on request). Look for the colors, the wording, the tow company’s name and number, and “tow.utah.gov”.
  3. Photograph every entrance yourself, with something in the frame for scale, and keep the original files where you made them. If a lot spans parcels, or has no clear entrance, check the 40-foot spacing rules (603(4)(b)(iii), (iv)).
  4. If the tow was from a fire lane, a hydrant or an accessible stall, the signs may not matter (603(3)(b)). Ask for the tow company’s photo as an original file, and its reported time of removal.
  5. If a 24-hour notice was used, ask for a copy of the notice with the exact time written on it, and the photo of it on the driver’s side window.
  6. Ask the tow company for its database report time and the certified letter receipt (603(1)). Without them it may have no right to the fees at all (603(2)(a), 603(22)(a)).
  7. Drop the tow company’s photos in together with its photos from other tows at your property. The checker marks any two files in the same batch that are the same file, even under different names. A photo reused from an earlier tow shows up that way. A new photo of a different night won’t, which is why the reported removal time matters more than the picture.

A gap here is a question, not a finding. Your office may have asked for the tow by phone and not written it down. The patrol agreement may sit with the owner, not with you. A sign may have been knocked down after the tow, which a later photo can’t tell apart from a sign that was never there. And the resident may be right.

What we don’t cover

Only this one Utah statute. The statute makes the private property rules “subject to the requirements of a local ordinance”, and we didn’t read any city’s towing ordinance. We didn’t read the Department of Transportation’s towing rules or rates, its published sign examples, Utah Code 41-6a-1406 (which the statute uses to say who has an interest in a towed car), court decisions, or whether a property owner or manager can be liable to a resident for a tow. Colorado and the other Mountain West states regulate towing under their own laws, which we haven’t read for this piece.

Whether someone used AI on the photos

A photo of a car in a parking stall, or of a sign at an entrance, is easy to generate or edit now, and some generators write a mark into the file saying so. The checker reads those marks, and the notes some phone editors leave when generative AI was used to alter a photo. A file with no such mark is not proven real. Most fakes and most genuine photos look the same to a file reader once they have been through a chat app or a screenshot. And a genuine photo is still only a photo: the signs at every entrance, the request for the tow and the tow company’s report are what decide it.

The limits, stated plainly

Related: abandoned belongings charges in Utah and the posted notice (which doesn’t cover cars), and where you keep your own inspection photos.


ImposterShield reads the evidence inside image and video files. It runs in your browser and uploads nothing. If a file has been stripped, it says so. If it has not read a file, it says that too.

Check the tow photos before you answer the resident

Drop the resident’s and the tow company’s photos on the page together with your own photos of each entrance. It shows what each file says about when it was made, and marks any two that are the same file. A saved report lists each file’s SHA-256.

Open the checker