A gas-heated duplex in Colorado. Mid-lease, the maintenance vendor invoices $240 for “replace 2 CO alarms, missing/not working”, and the owner is asked to charge it to the tenant’s deposit at move-out. The photos show two new alarms on the hallway ceiling. They may be perfectly real. But a picture of an alarm doesn’t answer the two questions Colorado’s law actually turns on: when the alarm was replaced, and whether the tenant told the owner in writing. This piece covers what Colorado’s carbon monoxide alarm statute (C.R.S. Title 38, Article 45) says, and what to check before you pay the invoice or pass it on. It is not legal advice.
Why the photo can’t answer the question
A photo of an alarm on a ceiling shows a device. It doesn’t show that it works, that it is a carbon monoxide alarm rather than a smoke alarm, how far it is from the bedroom doors, or what was there before. And a photo of a new alarm looks the same whether it was installed at turnover, during the lease after a tenant’s note, or never at this address at all. The statute splits the cost by those facts, and those facts are on paper.
Which rentals the law covers
Article 45 reaches a rental in two ways. A dwelling “used for rental purposes that has a change in tenant occupancy on or after July 1, 2009” is covered (38-45-104(2)). So is one “that includes fuel-fired appliances or an attached garage” where work requiring a building permit happened on or after that date, such as “fuel-fired appliance replacements” (104(1)). “Fuel” means “coal, kerosene, oil, fuel gases, or other petroleum products or hydrocarbon products such as wood” (38-45-101(3)).
The requirement those rentals take on is the one for sellers and permit work: “an operational carbon monoxide alarm is installed within fifteen feet of the entrance to each room lawfully used for sleeping purposes”, or where a building code adopted by the state or a local government says (38-45-102 and 103). In a multi-family building, if “there is a centralized alarm system or other mechanism for a responsible person to hear the alarm at all times”, the alarm may instead go “within twenty-five feet of any fuel-fired heater or appliance, fireplace, or garage” (104(5)). Local governments may adopt rules “more stringent” than the statute (38-45-105).
We didn’t read the wording of 104(2) as a lawyer would, so whether it reaches a rental with no fuel-fired appliance and no attached garage is a question we leave to one. The furnace replacement case is covered in our piece on furnace replacement invoices and the permit record: the permit that proves the furnace work is also what brings the alarm rule in under 104(1).
What counts as an alarm
The definition is specific. A carbon monoxide alarm is a device that “Produces a distinct, audible alarm”, is “listed by a nationally recognized, independent product-safety testing and certification laboratory”, and is battery powered, plugged in with a battery backup, wired in with a battery backup, or “connected to an electrical system via an electrical panel” (101(1)). It can be combined with a smoke detector if the unit alarms “in a manner that clearly differentiates between the two hazards” (101(1)(d)). “Operational” means “working and in service in accordance with manufacturer instructions” (101(6)). A battery alarm counts as “installed” when it is “attached to the wall or ceiling” following the national fire protection association’s standard 720 (101(4)(c)). We haven’t read NFPA 720, so we don’t say what it requires.
Who pays for what
This is where the invoice question lives. The owner of a covered rental “shall” (104(3)(a)):
- At turnover: “Prior to the commencement of a new tenant occupancy, replace any carbon monoxide alarm that was stolen, removed, found missing, or found not operational after the previous occupancy”.
- At move-in: “Ensure that any batteries necessary to make the carbon monoxide alarm operational are provided to the tenant at the time the tenant takes residence”.
- During the lease, after notice: replace an alarm if notified by the tenant under 104(4)(c) that it was “stolen, removed, found missing, or found not operational during the tenant’s occupancy”, and “Fix any deficiency in a carbon monoxide alarm if notified by a tenant” under 104(4)(d).
Outside those duties, “the owner … is not responsible for the maintenance, repair, or replacement of a carbon monoxide alarm or the care and replacement of batteries for such an alarm” (104(3)(b)). The tenant, for their part, must “Keep, test, and maintain all carbon monoxide alarms in good repair” (104(4)(a)), and must notify the owner “or the owner’s authorized agent” in writing when batteries need replacing, when an alarm is stolen, removed, missing or not working, and of any deficiency “that the tenant cannot correct” (104(4)(b) to (d)). And “No person shall remove batteries from, or in any way render inoperable, a carbon monoxide alarm”, except to inspect, maintain, repair or replace it or its batteries (104(6)).
So the same $240 line means different things depending on the date and the paper behind it. Replaced before a new tenant moved in: the statute puts that on the owner. Replaced mid-lease after the tenant’s written notice: also on the owner. Replaced mid-lease with no notice, because an inspection found the batteries pulled: that is the situation where a deduction may be argued, and where the photo of the new alarm proves least. Whether any of it can be deducted from a deposit is a question for Colorado’s deposit law and your lawyer, not this statute. It doesn’t mention deposits.
Checks before you pay or deduct
- Find the date the work was done and put it next to the lease dates. Before a new tenant’s occupancy began is the 104(3)(a)(I) turnover duty, which is the owner’s.
- If it was mid-lease, look for the tenant’s written notice. 104(4)(b) to (d) asks for notice in writing to the owner or the owner’s authorized agent. A portal request or an email may be that notice; check your records before saying there was none.
- Ask what the vendor found, in words: missing, batteries out, past the manufacturer’s replacement date, or chirping. “Missing/not working” on an invoice covers all of those, and they point to different people.
- Ask for the model of the new alarm, and check it is a carbon monoxide alarm or a combined unit, not a smoke alarm alone. The listing requirement is in 101(1)(b).
- Check the location against the bedrooms. Within fifteen feet of the entrance to each sleeping room is the statute’s default. A photo of one alarm in a hall doesn’t show distances; a floor plan with the alarm marked does.
- Match the count to the unit. A two-bedroom unit billed for five alarms, or a duplex where both sides were billed the same day, is worth a question.
- Ask for the original photo files, not pictures pasted into an invoice PDF, which have usually lost their camera record. Why, and how to ask for the originals.
- Drop the photos in together with the same vendor’s photos from your other units. The checker marks any two files in the same batch that are the same file, even under different names. A photo of an alarm on a ceiling is one of the easiest pictures to reuse across jobs, because every ceiling looks alike. A new photo of a different ceiling won’t show up that way, which is why the dates and the notice matter more than the picture.
A gap here is a question, not a finding. The tenant may have phoned and the manager may have acted on it without asking for it in writing. The alarm may have reached its end of life with nobody at fault. The vendor may have taken one photo for two units because they look identical. And a vendor that can’t say what it found has told you something about its paperwork, not necessarily about the tenant.
If the tenant is the one with the photos
The same law works the other way. A tenant who says the alarm was dead on move-in day, with a photo of a blank display, is pointing at 104(3)(a)(I) and (II). That photo is evidence of a moment, not of the date it was taken or the unit it was taken in. Ask for the original file and when the tenant first wrote to you about it. Our piece on smoke alarm replacement invoices covers the date printed on the alarm itself.
What we don’t cover
Only Colorado’s statute. We didn’t read the building codes adopted by the state or any local government, any city or county carbon monoxide ordinance (which 105 allows to be stricter), NFPA 720, the real estate commission’s listing contract rules, or Colorado’s deposit and habitability statutes as they apply to alarms. We didn’t read the limitation of liability in 38-45-106 as a lawyer would, so we don’t say what it protects. Utah, Idaho, Arizona and the other Mountain West states handle carbon monoxide alarms differently, and we haven’t read their laws.
Whether someone used AI on the photos
A photo of a white alarm on a white ceiling is easy to generate now, and some generators write a mark into the file saying so. The checker reads those marks in photos, and the notes some phone editors leave when generative AI was used to alter a photo. A file with no such mark is not proven real. Most fakes and most genuine photos look the same to a file reader once they have been through a chat app or a screenshot. And a genuine photo is still only a photo: the dates and the tenant’s written notice are what decide whose bill it is.
The limits, stated plainly
- We read C.R.S. Title 38, Article 45 (38-45-101 to 106) in the Colorado Revised Statutes 2026 PDF published by the Office of Legislative Legal Services, in November 2026. Its source notes show the article was added in 2009 and last amended in 2019, in sections that don’t change the rental duties above.
- We did not read building codes, local ordinances, NFPA 720, real estate commission rules, or any other state’s law.
- Whether a particular rental is covered, whether a cost can be deducted from a deposit, and what 38-45-106 protects are legal questions we don’t answer.
- Our example is made up. We don’t know how often alarm replacements are mis-billed to rentals or to tenants.
- A photo with no camera record is not a fake. Text messages, chat apps and many portals remove the record from genuine photos every day.
- Our checker gives no confidence score and does not judge a picture by looking at it. It reads what is in the file, in your browser, and uploads nothing. A file with no AI marker is not proven real.
- This is not legal advice.
Related: furnace replacement invoices and the permit record, and Colorado repair records and the ten-day request.
ImposterShield reads the evidence inside image and video files. It runs in your browser and uploads nothing. If a file has been stripped, it says so. If it has not read a file, it says that too.
Check the vendor’s photos before you pay
Drop this job’s photos on the page together with photos from the same vendor’s other jobs. It shows what each file says about when it was made, and marks any two that are the same file. A saved report lists each file’s SHA-256.
Open the checker